In convex geometry, the volume of a shape is rarely studied in isolation. When we combine two convex bodies $K$ and $L$ through Minkowski addition—effectively sweeping one shape along the boundary of the other—the volume of the resulting sum $Vol(t_1K + t_2L)$ expands as a polynomial. The coefficients of this polynomial are known as mixed volumes. These values capture how different shapes interact geometrically, but their behavior is governed by complex constraints that have remained poorly understood for decades.
Recent breakthroughs have focused on characterizing the "extremals" of these constraints: the specific geometric conditions under which fundamental inequalities, such as the Alexandrov-Fenchel inequality, become equalities.
The Alexandrov-Fenchel Inequality
The Alexandrov-Fenchel (AF) inequality is the central pillar of this field. It states that mixed volumes are log-concave, generalizing the classical isoperimetric inequality. While the inequality itself is well-established, identifying the "equality cases"—the pairs of shapes that sit exactly on the boundary of the inequality—has been a notorious challenge.
The difficulty stems from the fact that mixed volumes are sensitive to the "smoothness" and dimensionality of the bodies involved. As noted by Ramon van Handel in Mixed volumes and the Bochner method, while spectral theory and the Bochner method can simplify the proof of the inequality itself, they do not immediately reveal the geometric nature of the extremals for non-smooth bodies.
Solving the Equality Problem
A major turning point occurred when Ramon van Handel completely characterized the equality cases for Minkowski’s quadratic inequality in The extremals of Minkowski’s quadratic inequality. This was achieved by connecting mixed volumes to degenerate elliptic operators, showing that equality is tied to the structure of the underlying measures.
For the broader Alexandrov-Fenchel inequality, the solution for convex polytopes was provided in The extremals of the Alexandrov–Fenchel inequality for convex polytopes. In this work, van Handel demonstrated that equality is achieved through three distinct geometric mechanisms:
- Translation: The bodies are shifts of one another.
- Support: The bodies share the same supporting hyperplanes in certain directions.
- Dimensionality: The bodies are degenerate in ways that collapse the volume calculation.
This unified framework explains why equality is so much harder to characterize than in simpler geometric settings: it is not just about the shapes being "the same," but about how their faces and normal vectors align.
Mapping the Space of Mixed Volumes
Beyond individual inequalities, researchers are attempting to map the entire space of possible mixed volumes. If you have four different planar shapes, what are the possible values their mixed areas can take?
Soprunov et al. addressed this in Plücker-Type Inequalities for Mixed Areas and Intersection Numbers of Curve Arrangements, introducing new inequalities that fully describe the space of mixed areas for up to four sets. These "Plücker-type" constraints show that mixed volumes are not independent; they are bound by algebraic relations similar to those found in tropical geometry.
For specific classes of shapes, like zonoids (sums of line segments), these relations become even more structured. Averkov et al. proved a Bézout-type inequality for 3D zonoids in An Algebraic-Combinatorial Proof of a Bézout-Type Inequality for Mixed Volumes of Three-Dimensional Zonoids, reducing a complex geometric bound to the non-negativity of squared real numbers through polyhedral subdivisions.
Constraints and Conjectures
The search for extremals also extends to "unbalanced" combinations of bodies. Godbersen’s conjecture, for instance, suggests that certain mixed volumes are maximized only for simplices (the simplest possible polytopes). Artstein-Avidan et al. explored this in On unbalanced difference bodies and Godbersen’s conjecture, proving that these conjectures hold "on average" and identifying simplices as the unique maximizers for specific linear combinations of mixed volumes.
Finally, the role of the support cone—the set of directions in which a body is "active"—is a critical frontier. Ziyi Zhang showed in Polyhedra of small relative mixed volume that for lattice polyhedra, those with minimal mixed volumes are "anchored" to a finite set of templates. However, Zhang notes that most current results assume the support cone is the positive orthant, leaving the behavior of mixed volumes in more exotic support cones as a major open question for singularity theory and beyond.
Key Foundational Work
Plücker-type inequalities for mixed areas and intersection numbers of curve arrangements (2022) — contributed 4 concept elements to this direction.
Mixed volumes and the Bochner method (2019) — contributed 2 concept elements to this direction.
The extremals of Minkowski’s quadratic inequality (2022) — contributed 2 concept elements to this direction.