In algebraic topology and geometry, we frequently study spaces by passing to their cohomology rings. In cohomology, algebraic operations often behave perfectly; for instance, the standard cup product is strictly graded-commutative. However, this perfection is an illusion of passing to equivalence classes. At the underlying cochain level—the actual combinatorial and algebraic data before taking kernels and quotients—the cup product is explicitly non-commutative.
If we discard the cochain level, we lose vital topological information. The failure of cochain-level commutativity is not a mere nuisance; it is the exact source of higher topological invariants, such as Steenrod operations. A growing body of research focuses on making these "almost commutative" or homotopy-coherent structures explicit, effective, and computable. By shifting from abstract derived categories to concrete cochain-level constructions, researchers are unlocking new computational tools and extending foundational invariants to highly complex geometric spaces.
The Core Mechanism: Operads and Cup-$i$ Products
To understand why this approach works, we must look at how to systematically govern the failure of commutativity. If two cochains $a$ and $b$ do not commute, their difference $ab - ba$ is not zero, but it is a coboundary of some higher-dimensional chain, denoted by a "cup-1" product $a \cup_1 b$. If these cup-1 products fail to satisfy higher symmetries, that failure is tracked by a cup-2 product, and so on.
This infinite cascade of higher homotopies is naturally encoded using algebraic structures called operads—specifically $E_\infty$-operads like the Barratt-Eccles or surjection operads. These operads act as templates that dictate exactly how multiplication commutes and associates up to coherent, higher-dimensional homotopies.
To make these abstract structures practical, Anibal M. Medina-Mardones introduced ComCH in A computer algebra system for the study of commutativity up to coherent homotopies. This Python package provides a concrete computational framework to define and manipulate operadic algebra and coalgebra structures directly on chain complexes.
By materializing these hidden homotopies, researchers can refine classical topological tools. For example, in Ranicki–Weiss assembly and the Steenrod construction, Anibal M. Medina-Mardones demonstrated that the Ranicki-Weiss assembly functor—a tool used to assemble global topological invariants from local data on simplicial complexes—can be fully faithfully factored through a refined category governed by the Steenrod cup-$i$ coalgebra. This proves that tracking explicit cochain-level homotopies yields a more structured, powerful algebraic model for assembly processes than traditional methods.
[Strict Commutativity] (Fails at Cochain Level)
│
▼
[Cup-i Products] ───► Driven by Operads (Barratt-Eccles / Surjection)
│
▼
[Computable Invariants] (Steenrod Operations, Cartan Relators)
Effective Proofs via Cartan Relators and Adem Relations
Historically, many fundamental relations governing cohomology operations—such as the Adem relations and the Cartan formula—were proven using abstract, non-constructive methods that bypassed explicit cochain calculations. While these proofs established that the formulas were true, they hid the underlying algebraic machinery.
Recent work revitalizes these foundations by providing effective, constructive proofs directly on the cochain level. In A cochain level proof of Adem relations in the mod 2 Steenrod algebra, G. W. Brumfiel et al. focused on a specific proof technique that explicitly constructs the cochain-level equations governing the mod 2 Steenrod algebra.
This constructive philosophy is pushed further for odd primes by Federico Cantero-Morán et al. in An effective proof of the Cartan formula: odd primes. The authors introduced a novel framework of "cup-$(p,i)$ products" and Cartan relators. A Cartan relator is an explicitly constructed chain homotopy between maps; the authors proved that the very existence of these relators is logically equivalent to the validity of the Cartan formula. By utilizing the Barratt-Eccles operad to equip the cochains of simplicial sets with a robust May-Steenrod structure, the authors turned an abstract topological truth into a concrete, programmable algebraic reality.
Extending the Philosophy to Algebraic Stacks
The power of replacing abstract derived categories with explicit, simplicial, and cochain-level frameworks is not confined to topology; it solves deep problems in algebraic geometry as well.
A prime example is the study of deformations and obstructions on complex geometric spaces like algebraic stacks. The primary tool for this, the Atiyah class, was historically restricted to smooth varieties and perfect complexes. For more general moduli spaces—which are frequently algebraic stacks and involve highly complex, quasi-coherent sheaves—defining the Atiyah class traditionally stalled because the standard tools could not easily handle the non-derived, highly singular nature of these spaces.
In The Atiyah class on algebraic stacks, Nikolas Kuhn bypassed these limitations by generalizing the Atiyah class to arbitrary algebraic stacks. Crucially, the author achieved this by leveraging simplicial methods and the Dold-Kan correspondence to build the theory from the ground up without relying on abstract derived categories.
This mirrors the topological breakthrough: by utilizing explicit simplicial resolutions and chain-level representations, one can construct robust invariants on intricate geometric stacks where classical smooth methods fail. Whether computing the fine-grained shape of a data space via cup-$i$ products or mapping the deformation space of an algebraic stack, the core insight remains the same: tracking the explicit, coherent homotopies at the chain level provides a deeper, more constructive understanding than looking at the surface level alone.
Key Foundational Work
Correction to: A cochain level proof of Adem relations in the mod 2 Steenrod algebra (2022) — contributed 4 concept elements to this direction.
A computer algebra system for the study of commutativity up-to-coherent homotopies (2021) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.